KALAMAZOO, Michigan Renewing a rivalry that dates back to 1912, the Eastern Michigan Eagles and Western Michigan Broncos met on the gridiron for the 58th time, with both teams looking for something different.
For Eastern Michigan, with a Mid-American Conference title already out of reach and a three-game losing streak, the Eagles traveled to Kalamazoo with only one thing in mind: survival.
To reach a bowl game for the first time since 2023, Eastern Michigan needed to survive and win its final two regular-season games to reach the elusive six-win mark that would send the team to the postseason.
The only thing standing in its way was the 7-3 Western Michigan Broncos, who had their sights set on a MAC championship game appearance for the second consecutive year as they looked to retain their title as MAC champions.
The Eagles, saddled with a three-game losing streak against the Broncos and relying on backup quarterbacks, quickly discovered that earning an extra game at the end of the regular season would be an uphill battle.
On the first play from scrimmage, Western Michigan running back Jalen Buckley took it the distance with a 72-yard touchdown, putting the Broncos up seven just 8 seconds into the game.
A roughing-the-passer penalty on Eastern Michigan's first play from scrimmage wiped away a Western Michigan interception, but the Eagles couldn't sustain the drive and were forced to punt. Offensive lineman Elijah Payne was also helped off the field with an injury.
The Broncos regained possession and marched down the field, capping the drive with a 1-yard touchdown run from Buckley. The score marked his 40th touchdown with the Broncos, giving him sole possession of third place on Western Michigan's all-time rushing touchdown list.
A muffed punt by the Broncos was recovered by the Eagles, giving Eastern Michigan possession at the Western Michigan 7-yard line.
Amareon Blue did the rest, sprinting around the left side of his offensive line and into the end zone for a 7-yard score, cutting the Western Michigan lead in half.
After the Eagles' touchdown, Western Michigan marched all the way to the visitors' 3-yard line, but a valiant bend-but-don't-break defensive effort forced the Broncos to turn the ball over on downs, keeping Eastern Michigan within seven points.
Looking to capitalize on the momentum gained from the fourth-down stop, the Eagles, in Dan Campbell fashion, decided to go for it on fourth-and-1 from their own 24-yard line.
Unfortunately for Eastern Michigan, the Broncos saw through the wildcat play design and stopped Braydon Bennett for no gain, regaining possession deep in Eagle territory.
After a shaky start, Eastern Michigan's defense was beginning to find its rhythm. The Eagles stopped the Broncos from gaining a first down and forced a 36-yard field goal. The kick extended the Broncos' lead to 10 but kept the Eagles within striking distance.
The momentum wouldn't last long, as the Eagle offense couldn't do anything with the football, punting it back to the Broncos, who gladly accepted possession with less than two minutes remaining in the first half.
Western Michigan then reached the end zone in just five plays, aided by two 15-yard personal foul penalties. The Broncos stretched their lead to 24-7 with a 2-yard touchdown run from former Michigan Wolverine running back Cole Cabana.
The bad times were far from over for Eastern Michigan. Quarterback Jace Stuckey was caught trying to force a throw to the outside, which was intercepted by cornerback Dillon Moore and returned 50 yards for a pick-six with two seconds remaining before halftime.
The Eagles entered the break trailing 31-7, with their postseason hopes quickly slipping away. The team was now facing another year without a bowl game appearance.
Their only opportunity in the second half was to avoid further embarrassment before heading back to Ypsilanti with a four-game losing streak and one final game remaining in the 2026 season.
The Eagles had been outgained 240-78 in total yards, with 171 of Western Michigan's yards coming on the ground.
Eastern Michigan's ground game was also responsible for most of the team's production, with only seven of its 78 yards coming through the air.
After the disastrous ending to the first half, Eagles head coach Chris Creighton went to his bench, replacing Stuckey with the other backup quarterback, Brogan McCaughey, who had started the previous two games against Central Michigan and Ohio.
The change proved fruitful as McCaughey completed all three of his passes before Blue broke free for a 41-yard touchdown run, his second of the night.
The score cut the Broncos' lead to 18, but a failed two-point conversion attempt kept the Eagles trailing with more than 11 minutes remaining in the third quarter.
McCaughey once again proved to be the right decision as he led the Eagles back down the field after the Broncos went three-and-out.
McCaughey completed another three passes, including a 30-yard completion to Nick Devereaux while scrambling to his left and throwing with his right hand.
A 1-yard touchdown catch by tight end Joshua Long finished the drive, cutting the Eagles' deficit to 11 with just under six minutes remaining in the third quarter. The catch also rewrote the record books, as Long now holds the record for most receptions in a single season by a tight end in Eastern Michigan history.
With their lead suddenly dwindling, the Western Michigan Broncos put together an eight-minute drive, covering 64 yards before kicking a 27-yard field goal to extend their lead to 14 points with 12:45 remaining in the game.
Although Eastern Michigan's momentum was briefly stalled, it quickly returned as the Eagles made a point of running the football directly at the Broncos, attempting just three passes on their way to another touchdown.
The Eagles covered 65 yards in 11 plays, ending the drive with another Blue touchdown to complete his hat trick. With seven and a half minutes remaining, Eastern Michigan had clawed its way back to within seven after trailing by 24 at halftime.
After forcing another Broncos punt, Eastern Michigan had one final opportunity to tie or win the game with just under two minutes remaining.
The Eagles managed to reach the Western Michigan 25-yard line before the Broncos' defense turned them away with a turnover on downs, putting an end to the comeback and sending Eastern Michigan back to Ypsilanti with its fourth consecutive loss.
The win gave Western Michigan its eighth victory of the season and its third consecutive MAC win.
Although Eastern Michigan came up short, the Eagles held one of the MAC's best offenses to just three points in the second half. Had things not unraveled so badly in the opening 30 minutes, there was a real possibility the Eagles could have walked away with a victory.
After the game, Creighton discussed both halves of the contest and the difficult loss that ended his team's bowl game hopes.
"Yeah. Beginning of the game, we're ready to go and whatnot. And then we had a horrible first half. And so we came in at halftime, we're down 7 to 31, and we talked about how we're not going to have penalties. We're going to play how we play. We're going to play really hard, not going to hang our heads. There's not going to be any defeat whatsoever. And it's not going to be this surface-level, rah-rah. We're going to play football the way we know how to play it, and we're going to play it together. We're going to play it really hard, and we're going to come back. And, you know, that doesn't happen without a bunch of dudes who've got real character," he said.
"And, you know, it wasn't some crazy momentum. There weren't like these crazy plays and we had some scrambles. We threw the ball downfield and got some chunks and all that, but it wasn't like a 4-takeaway deal in the second half and balls bouncing off a helmet, and we're scoring. It wasn't like that at all. We just played good football and, again, gave ourselves a chance to win at the end. So I told them the first half can't happen. It just can't happen. I'm not yelling and screaming. And then I'm super proud of the way that our guys were able to keep it together and to fight the second half and give ourselves a chance to win. And then we're all furious that we didn't."
Despite the loss, Eastern Michigan showed plenty of fight after halftime, turning what appeared to be a one-sided contest into a game that came down to the final possession. The comeback ultimately fell short, but the second-half performance offered a glimpse of what the Eagles are capable of when they put together four quarters of football.
Eastern Michigan will now turn its attention to its regular-season finale, looking to end its losing streak and close out the 2026 campaign on a positive note.

